Cultural Appropriations · Rants For Thought

The Onion’s Racist Treatment of Quvenzhané Wallis At The 2013 Oscars

Update to this post: The Onion has apologized for their tweet regarding Quvenzhané Wallis here.

I love the Oscars. Every year, I sit down happily with wine and treats to watch the movies that I’ve been checking out and loving get nominated and honoured. This year, “Les Miserables” was my favourite, and I really highly enjoyed the performances by the cast and the speeches being made by everyone involved. The Oscars didn’t disappoint in its general award-ceremoniness – except then it did.

You may have heard of a small film called “Beasts of the Southern Wild”, starring a nine-year-old girl named Quvenzhané Wallis. Wallis gave an incredible performance as Hushpuppy, a six-year-old girl who lives with her sick father on an isolated island in Louisiana. She carried the entire film with her narrative, expressive acting, and wonderful dialogue. She was nominated for Best Actress, and deserved her nomination wholeheartedly.

Somehow, instead of the world being proud of Wallis, her nomination caused confusion and even skepticism. People felt she was too young to be considered a favourite to win and “had time”. One idiotic anonymous Oscar voter decreed he wasn’t going to “vote for someone whose name I can’t pronounce.” When Wallis came to the red carpet tonight, happy and excited to be attending a party where she was being honoured for her work, people mispronounced her name. One reporter went so far as to tell her that she was going to call Wallis “Annie” instead of her name, Quvenzhané. Wallis firmly corrected her – her name is not Annie, though she is going to play the title role in a remake of the movie.

The jokes went on. Onscreen, Seth MacFarlane decided to make a very distasteful joke about Wallis being “too old for [George] Clooney in another nine years”, which caused uncomfortable laughter and a lot of outrage from feminists, parents, and decent people alike. But the worst of the worst was when The Onion, on its Twitter feed, decided to refer to Wallis as a “c*nt”, trying to crack a joke that fell horribly flat and disgusted social media everywhere. Since that’s been deleted, here’s a screenshot of the homepage:

Screenshot taken by @laripley
Screenshot taken by @laripley

There are a lot of people who say we live in a post-racial, post-misogynistic society. And I’d like to ask them how they draw that conclusion when a little nine-year-old girl who is also a woman of colour gets sexualized, joked about, and generally put down on what’s supposed to be one of the biggest nights of her life. How a night that’s supposed to honour her turns into this.

I’d also like to ask them how they can say that this is “subversive” humour, or tell everyone that it’s “just The Onion” or “just Seth MacFarlane and his humour”. For one, I’ve never seen a little white girl get treated the way Wallis was treated tonight. Secondly, I find it very odd that a nine-year-old girl getting treated this way is considered normal enough to some people to find it funny. How can you laugh at a child being called a c*nt and sexualized?

I’m not a person of colour (POC). I can’t speak for how Wallis and her family must feel to have heard these insults, and what’s more, to not have them even apologized or atoned for. The Onion deleted its tweet about Wallis and at the time of this writing, has not apologized publicly to her at all. It has not even acknowledged its horrible mistake in publishing that tweet. Seth MacFarlane has not apologized for sexualizing a nine-year-old.

I’m not going to comment on how POC must feel about this or how Wallis must feel about it; it’s not my place as a white person to do so. Instead, I’m going to direct you to a woman of colour who can tell you in no uncertain terms exactly what was wrong with tonight and how Wallis was treated. This is not just misogynistic behaviour. This is racist. This is wrong. And no one should be standing for this or finding it funny.

If you’d like to tell The Onion how you feel about Quvenzhané Wallis’ treatment tonight, please call or write to them at 212 E Superior St; Chicago, IL 60611, phone number 312-751-0503. This is not okay, nor should it ever be considered okay. Or you can tweet them at @TheOnion, though they don’t appear to be responding to tweets about this. If you want to contact Seth MacFarlane for his jailbait joke, his Twitter is @SethMacFarlane. Since the Onion has just taken contact info down from their website at the time of this writing, it’s even more important to tell them how you feel about what just happened to Wallis tonight.

I’m pretty proud of Wallis. She’s an extremely talented actress who deserved to be honoured, not put down and objectified. This is the continuation of racism in our modern culture. It needs to be recognized and stopped before more children are hurt and more women are objectified. What should have happened is that she should have been congratulated and celebrated.

You know, like the other actresses in her category were. And the other young actresses who shared being young Oscar nominees with her were.

The only difference is, they’re white, and she’s not.

See the problem here?

Image taken from ibtimes.com
Image taken from ibtimes.com – Quvenzhané Wallis as Hushpuppy in “Beasts of the Southern Wild”
Advertisements

14 thoughts on “The Onion’s Racist Treatment of Quvenzhané Wallis At The 2013 Oscars

  1. This is the dumbest feminist concern trolling I’ve read in 2 days. The joke is she’s not a cunt but a cute 9 year old. This is one of the longest-running jokes about child actors. You clearly have too many feminist word proteins in your brain.

    1. Agreed. The author of this blog is clearly a closet racist herself trying to act the way she thinks someone who isn’t racist would act. A pathetic ruse.

  2. You’ve never seen a white girl treated this way, because your racist blinders aren’t on the look out for that. Again, the joke stems from her being a cute girl. I’m certain that the same jokes were told about Dakota Fanning (and other young white actresses), and Google would most likely confirm that. Before you call others racist, take a look at yourself. Every joke or slight of a non-white is somehow racist to you. You clearly have not reached the stage of post-racial.

    1. Appropriately, the outrage is this “child” being called the C word. Bringing racism into this dialogue is an obvious marketing tool to get the author noticed, accomplished, or I wouldn’t have seen her remarks. Several others have brought racism or color into this, inappropriately so. The message is then lost. She is a child. I am from Louisiana, about 60 miles from this girl’s hometown and where the movie was filmed and have spent many days and nights there in Houma. These people will eat The Onion author alive and you too. Its a multicultural town living and loving in relative harmony. We love her and all of our peoples and will defend and protect this beautiful child against all of YOU who would utilize her to accelerate your own profiles. Shameful.

  3. In my opinion as a “woman of color,” you are the racist one. You seem to not understand any “racial slur” because you are white. White is not a race. Peoples of the white race are: Hispanic, North African, Middle Eastern and European. And all of those “white” people have suffered discrimination. I forgot to mention white Jews and white gypsies. You act as though you can’t relate which makes you the racist. You took out of context what was said. Whenever children do amazing things that are adult in nature there are jokes to that affect. They did not call her a cunt in the way you describe. If that is what you inferred from reading that on twitter then you are the racist idiot. And by the way her name is very hard to pronounce. I am biracial and I can’t pronounce any better than you. Get over it. Nobody in my black community was offended.

Tell me what you think!

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s